
Playlist
One of the nicer things in the last 20 years of pop music are rubinations, after Rick Rubin, an early innovator in it:
- an over-the-hill musician
- is renewed, accrues critical acclaim
- from working with a young svengali producer,
- on an album containing covers (especially surprising ones).
- The festival circuit
- or very large sales follow.
May-September music.
- Johnny Cash (& Rick Rubin) - American Recordings (1994-2003).
Satisfies #1, 2, 3, 4, 6.
- Loretta Lynn (& Jack White) - on 2004’s Van Lear Rose.
Satisfies 1, 2, 3, 4.
- Mavis Staples (& Jeff Tweedy) - 2010’s You Are Not Alone (and others). 1, 3, 4.
- Wanda Jackson (& Jack White) - on 2011’s The Party Ain’t Over.
Satisfies 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 & perhaps soon 6.
- Shirley Bassey (& the world) - on 2008’s The Performance. Satisfies 1,2,3,4,5, and of course 6.
- Neil Diamond (& Rick Rubin)- on 2005’s 12 Songs.
Satisfies 1,3,4,5 & 6.
- Vashti Bunyan (& Max Richter & Animal Collective!) - on 2005’s Lookaftering.
1, 2, 3, 4, 6.
- Bettye Lavette (& Joe Henry) - on 2005’s I’ve Got My Own Hell To Raise.
1,2,3,4,5.
- Willie Nelson (& Daniel Lanois) - on 1998’s Teatro.
Satisfies 1,4,6.
- Willie Nelson (& Ryan Adams) - on 2004’s Songbird.
Satisfies 1,2,4,5,6.
- Howlin Wolf (& Norman Dayron) - on 1971’s The London Sessions.
Satisfies 1,2,3,4.
- Muddy Waters (& Johnny Winter) - on 1977’s Hard Again.
1,2,3.
Embedding forbidden, but click here. The best single blues session?
- Leonard Cohen (& Sharon Robinson) - on 2001’s Ten New Songs.
2,3,6.
- RL Burnside (& Jon Spencer) - on 1996’s A Ass Pocket of Whiskey and others.
1,3,4.
- John Fahey (& Jim O’Rourke) - on 1997’s Womblife.
1,3,4.
- Glen Campbell - 2008’s Meet Glen Campbell, cover dreck.
1,3,5.
- Gil Scott-Heron (& Richard Russell) - on 2010’s I’m New Here.
1,2,3,4.
- Roky Erikson (& Will Sheff) - on 2010’s True Love Will Cast Out All Evil.
Satisfies 1 and 3.
- Candi Staton (& Mark Nevers) - 2006’s His Hands.
1,3,4,5.
- Robert Plant (& T-Bone Burnett) - on 2006’s Raising Sand.
1,2,3,4,6.
- Jimmy Cliff (with Tim Armstrong!) on Rebirth (2012)
1, 2, 3, 4
- The Stooges (& Steve Albini) on The Weirdness.
1,3,6.
[No.]
Tucker Zimmerman (& Big Thief) on Dance of Love
Tom Jones continues to try, but he didn’t rise anywhere in the first place, and so did not fall, and so cannot be renewed.

Alt-washing
A less exalted mirror image of these albums, though: pop stars having one album produced by a high-cred cult figure. While it's easy to interpret rubinations - producers are music nerds, rebirth is a deep and appealing trope everywhere and always - I do not pretend to know what these mean.
Tim Armstrong (P!nk)
Howe Gelb (KT Tunstall)
Bill Laswell (Motorhead, Ramones)
Odd choice, I grant you: but the point is that, however revered they are, these are two of the least experimental rock bands.
Jon Brion (Sky Ferreira)
Steve Albini (The Cribs)
Glyn Johns (Linda Ronstadt)
I could've made this list easier by just doing "surprising producers" - John Darnielle and Erik Rutan,
Tim Armstrong (P!nk)
Howe Gelb (KT Tunstall)
Bill Laswell (Motorhead, Ramones)
Odd choice, I grant you: but the point is that, however revered they are, these are two of the least experimental rock bands.
Jon Brion (Sky Ferreira)
Steve Albini (The Cribs)
Glyn Johns (Linda Ronstadt)
I could've made this list easier by just doing "surprising producers" - John Darnielle and Erik Rutan,